Home

Ideas need a place to grow.  To contribute create a free account.
[ watch intro video - very funny ] [ read more ] Create IdeaPals.org Account

Hannibal Rising Movie Review Analysis And Commentary

02/04/2010 22:35
America/Los Angeles
Type: 
Original Article

hannibalris.jpg Being a big fan of the Thomas Harris books and the films they have been turned into meant that I was quite excited about watching Hannibal Rising. Unfortunately my excitement was short lived as this film was in my opinion a true letdown to the rest of the series. *Spoilers Ahead* The film was supposed to show why Hannibal Lecter is so twisted. Sorry, but am I the only one who prefers NOT to know this? I like the fact that this guy is unpredictable and that we don't know the ins and outs of his history. Furthermore, now that I do actually know the whole story I'm not even that impressed with it! We now know the reason that Hannibal is such a nutcase and that his craving from human flash came from being held prisoner by soldiers as a child. Whilst he and his sister were captured during the war the soldiers decided to kill and eat Hannibal's sister Mischa in order to survive the harsh conditions they were all trapped in, they even fed some to Hannibal whilst he passed in and out of consciousness.

This prompted an older Hannibal to later seek them out and hunt them down one by one to make them pay for Mischa's death and forcing him into the unthinkable act of eating his own sister. Whilst I see the point they are trying to make here, and the fact that something truly dramatic and sickening had to happen to start Hannibal's obsession for flesh and killing as a mother I could barely look at the scenes of Mischa being poked and prodded ready to eat. This wasn't because they were too gory, but the simple fact that I think it's a completely disturbing plotline. I didn't think much to Gaspard Ulliel's portrayal of Lecter throughout the film, and believe he was wrongly cast, he bears no resemblance at all to Anthony Hopkins older Hannibal and whilst that's not the most important thing it certainly had an impact on the way I viewed the movie. His attempts at being dry and sarcastic in places were lost on me and although he was definitely creepy yet strangely charming I just didn't think he fit the role. Did anyone else think differently?

I loved Rhys Ifan's role as Grutas! He gave an energetic and menacing performance which was perhaps the movie's saving grace as far as I'm concerned. Gong Li was also great as Hannibal's aunt. For me, although I know that the whole point of this movie was to tell of Hannibal's childhood and the earlier years of his life, I found it a little too slow paced and drawn out with nothing like the same amounts of gore, action and excitement that are present in the other films. Maybe some of you out there disagree with me on this one, so feel free to hit reply and let me know your thoughts either way!

Status: 
Done

Comments

Personally I loved this film,

Personally I loved this film, although I expect I am in the minority. Yes it isn't made in the same vain as the previous movies, but it was never intended to follow in their footsteps - instead showing who he was and why.

Gaspard Ulliel was cast brilliantly as Hannibal Lector, maybe his resemblance to Anthony hopkins was a little weak, but he was "charming yet creepy" as is the character in the later movies *in timeframe*

The story was strong and told the tale of Hannibal's childhood from son to a wealthy family, to the twisted killer he is in his later life, and the reasons this little boy became the monster he is.

Post new comment

CAPTCHA
This question is for testing whether you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.
5 + 1 =
Solve this simple math problem and enter the result. E.g. for 1+3, enter 4.


IdeaPals - business social networking groups, entrepreneur meetups, events, project management, free job listings

Ideas need a place to grow. Create an idea group at IdeaPals.org and post events, jobs, videos, set goals, manage tasks and much more.
IdeaPals.org is part of MoviePals Entertainment, LLC Tel : 1.877.888.3350 E-mail: support@moviepals.com