Home

Ideas need a place to grow.  To contribute create a free account.
[ watch intro video - very funny ] [ read more ] Create IdeaPals.org Account

Updated datesort icon Title Author Replies Type
02/28/2010 - 11:14 Watch the Auditions Live Show - Creating the Mob Mentality Series support Original Article
02/17/2010 - 23:57 Comments on the Open Source Free Movie Boy Who Never Slept support 33 Original Article
02/17/2010 - 22:38 Get Source Files Video Footage, Audio, Script, Soundtrack support Original Article
02/11/2010 - 01:38 My Paranormal Review? (Paranormal Activity) HilaryHilary Original Article
02/08/2010 - 15:37 Slumdog Millionaire: B. I thought it was OK. Movie Commentary, Review, Analysis HilaryHilary 4 Original Article
02/08/2010 - 15:15 The Other Boleyn Girl- NOOOOo NOT THAT ONE! Movie Review, Analysis, Commentary HilaryHilary 4 Original Article
02/08/2010 - 15:14 Monsters vs. Aliens 3D: WINNER!!! Movie Review, Commentary, Analysis HilaryHilary 8 Original Article
02/08/2010 - 15:07 Observe and Report! Here's mine! Movie Analysis Review, Commentary HilaryHilary Original Article
02/08/2010 - 15:06 Crank 2: High Voltage Kinda Makes Me Cranky: Movie Review, Analysis, Commentary HilaryHilary 2 Original Article
02/08/2010 - 14:45 Watch Free Movies Online support Original Article
02/06/2010 - 14:16 Uncandid.org now blogs about Movies! HilaryHilary Opinion or Rant
02/05/2010 - 21:30 About MoviePals Open Cinema support Original Article
02/05/2010 - 21:09 Titanic was GIGANTIC! (even today! In my heart!) Movie Analysis, Commentary, Review support 4 Original Article
02/05/2010 - 21:07 OTIS--Please Kidnap Me! Movie Commentary, Analysis, Review support 1 Original Article
02/05/2010 - 21:05 BOTCHED-- Quite bit funny of a movie, yes. Movie Commentary, Analysis, Review support 2 Original Article
02/05/2010 - 21:03 The Reader--I know the secret and I would have blabbed. Movie Commentary, Review, Analysis support 3 Original Article
02/05/2010 - 21:01 Hamlet 2 and I am too? Movie Review, Commentary, Analysis support 1 Original Article
02/05/2010 - 20:59 Penelope- Oinky Meaningful Cuteness! Movie Analysis, Review, Commentary support Original Article
02/05/2010 - 20:57 Outrageousmagacious! MACHINE GIRL Movie Review, Analysis, Commentary support 2 Original Article
02/05/2010 - 20:55 Severance is Severely Wonderful! Movie Review, Commentary, Analysis support Original Article
02/05/2010 - 20:53 Watching Watchmen. Movie Review, Commentary, Analysis support 13 Original Article
02/05/2010 - 20:51 My Nearly Phantasmic Experience (Phantasm 1979): Movie Analysis Commentary Review support 1 Original Article
02/05/2010 - 20:49 Coraline 3D-- Animation and Themes are Cute as a Button. Movie commentary Analysis Review support 8 Original Article
02/05/2010 - 20:47 House Bunny-- kicked OUT of MY house! Movie Analysis, Review, Commentary support 9 Original Article
02/05/2010 - 20:45 I'm SOOO into "He's Just Not That Into You" Movie Analysis Review Commentary support 8 Original Article

There are no jobs or projects in this group. You can be the first to create one.

There are no Deciders in this group. You can be the first to create one.

There are no new To Do's in your groups.

What the critics of graphic horror movies or so called “torture porn” don’t understand.

02/04/2010 22:35
America/Los Angeles
Type: 
Original Article

Hostel Movie Poster Question: Why do most people watch horror movies? Answer: They like to get scared. Now getting scared is too broad an answer and not directly measurable, so I'm going to narrow it down a bit. What happens when you're scared or your body senses a threat? It produces adrenaline, heightens your senses and increases your heartbeat. Many people believe they no longer get scared by horror movies; however, though they may not jump or scream or have nightmares, their body does react. It increases heart rate, blood flow and creates a whole host of emotions. The "scarier" the horror movie, the greater the effect it has on your senses.

It's simple: the horror movies that "scare" some people or produce adrenaline for them and increase their heart beats, creating an intense experience, do nothing for me. They're like watching a kid's movie. For me, and many other genre fans like me, horror movies on the light side (PG 13, non-graphic R) don't produce any adrenaline because they simply aren't scary enough. In fact, they're often laughable. If I want to get "scared" or have an adrenaline rush that is intense and sucks me into the movie and characters, I need scarier nightmares. I need to feel the pain and see the threat (not just imagine it with spooky shadows).

It's easy for me to imagine how offensive or repulsive graphically violent horror films could appear to a critic who finds milder movies (e.g. ghost or suspense films with shadowy figures) scary enough to stimulate their adrenaline glands. You don't need to see graphic pain and violence to get the "scare" or body response you're looking for. Instead, looking at those types of images goes over your "comfort threshold" and fills you with nothing but disgust at the film. Imagine if the PG 13 and light R rated horror films you like did absolutely nothing for you. Didn't even raise your heart beat a little. Were laughable instead of scary. Now you can imagine how hardcore horror fans feel. People have liked being scared for centuries (possibly since the beginning of human existence).

It's not weird or strange that I like to watch or see a movie that 'scares' me (e.g. adrenaline, increased heart beat). The 'regular' horror films with stupid sounds in the distance, cutaways, or "oh look it's there and now it's not" antics just don't cut it. I need something dark and visceral, something that could actually happen, something that defies reason and gives me a visual sense of pain. That's frightening, it's horrific, it makes my heart race faster and sucks me into the characters on the screen. It makes me want them to escape or kill their tormentors. It gives me the feelings I want when I watch a horror film. The SAME feeling you want when you watch a horror film, I just have to go a lot more graphic and bloody to get the same reaction. If you watched the old 1940's Frankenstein and Dracula movies, I doubt you'd be very scared of them or be full of anything other than historical admiration or laughter at how silly the movie is by today's standards and absolutely unable to inspire anything resembling the symptoms of fear.

So to your 1940's counterpart, even our most mild horror films would appear like torture porn does now. E.g. horrifying and disgusting. It's simple - the old Frankenstein and Dracula movies don't scare your anymore because you need scarier nightmares; you've gradually become desensitized. Graphic horror films which depict sadistic violence provide a much darker, sicker, scarier nightmare than anything currently out there. Many critics say real horror comes from what you don't see, but I beg to differ. Let's hook them up and measure their heart beat and adrenaline as they watch some of the sadistic torture scenes in Saw 3, or Hostel 2, or the Masters of Horror Imprint. I guarantee their vital signs will be off the chart, with increased heart beat and heightened senses, meaning they're "scared." And this is exactly what a horror movie is for, right? I still need decent character development and a good plot.

I watch horror movies to be immersed in a dark world that provides me with scary nightmares and makes me feel for the characters and become attached to their fates. I watch it for the experience. I LOVE horror movies. Ever since I was little kid I liked to be scared, to dream of monsters and to have my heart beat raise as I got sucked into a life and death story involving the darker elements of being human. I understand that to critics and people that never watch horror movies, they appear repulsive, but please understand that many of the films that seem intense and fill you with adrenaline can't satisfy what I watch horror movies for. The new style of bloodier, gorier, more intense films is not going away. It's created from a generation that grew up on horror movies and fell in love with being scared. It's the natural progression of the genre and it's only going to get "worse."

Target Date: 
Thu, 02/04/2010
Status: 
Done

Comments

This is ridiculous!!

You speak of a person's desensitisation to excessive and gratuitous violence and gore in a positive light? Let me ask you something; when you experience this type of masochistic euphoria, is it because you are petrified or is it because you get some kind of perverse pleasure in watching a man being viscously castrated or a woman getting a blowtorch in the face. In other words, are you really an adrenaline addict or are you just a sadist following in the footsteps of men like Vlad III the Impaler.

Since I suffer the burden of having a sadomasochistc friend, I have reluctantly accompanied him to virtually every egregious remake produced this decade of crappy 80’s slasher and splatter film along with entries in the disgusting torture porn genre mentioned above, so please note I have had experience. First of all, I would like to point out that none of these films have had anything even resembling good mise-en-scene. The music is awful – where are the shrieking violins of Bernard Herrmann or the menacing black mass Gregorian chants of Jerry Goldsmith? –; the acting can only be rivalled by that of a plank of wood; the scripts are poorly constructed and full of infantile logic and reason, not to mention being intellectually void; the cinematography is basic; and the direction is uninspired. So combine all those elements with high levels of revolving and unrealistic violence, and you have yourself sheer and unadulterated crapulence. And since I can only ‘connect’ with a film when it is well made, these films have very rarely actually scared me, rather they have simply revolved me, and how anyone other than a sadist can enjoy being revolved is beyond me.

Now don’t go off thinking I’m against violence or horror, – The Night of the Hunter, Psycho, Cape Fear (1962), The Birds, Repulsion, Rosemary’s Baby, Duel, Frenzy, The Exorcist, The Stepford Wives (1975), The Omen (1976), Invasion of the Body Snatchers (1956 and 1978), The Vanishing, The Silence of the Lambs, The Sixth Sense, and The Others are among my favourite films – but what I am against is two-and-a-half-hour gore fests that lack any type of subtlety, depth or finesse.

I wouldn’t so readily embrace your love of these films, if I were you. Instead, I would immediately arrange an appointment with certified psychiatrist.

Someone recently told me that

Someone recently told me that it was Joss Whedon who started this whole phrasing of ‘torture porn’ I really hope this isn’t true as I love this guys work and totally disagree with the terming of ‘Torture Porn’ I believe that its more a case of one film like Saw or Hostel taking a bold new direction and moving the horror genre on a whole to a completely new level. Films can’t stay the same forever and new, exciting and different things are always bound to be brought out that push the boundaries and take us out of our comfort zone. There will probably be a new craze soon in filmmaking and people will have another style to complain about. However I’m sure the true horror fans like me will still be in their element loving every second of these innovative, scary and downright twisted films eagerly anticipating what’s next! lol.

My response to the above

My response to the above comment:

Is there a general movie-going audience? Why would you go see a hardcore horror movie if you didn't like them? I think these movies tend to get negative reviews and have negative things published about them even if they are quality to their intended audience. Look at the review for SAW 1. The first in a series that launched an entire horror franchise, heavily influenced proceeding horror movies, did extremely well financially, was received very well in the horror community and the critics tore it apart calling it garbage, "cheap thrills", "hellish extremes more oppressive than entertaining", "...nothing but a glorified snuff film". This is a perfect example of what my blog post is about. These critics (http://www.rottentomatoes.com/m/saw/) definitely didn't understand or want to think about what's in that post. They didn't rate that film based on it's intended audience who likes to get "scare" or see an adrenaline filled movie, they rated it off their own internal bias and inability to enjoy it, which is a shame.

reposted comment from

reposted comment from digg:
"I think you are preaching to the choir here. The 'average' critic reviews movies based on the general movie-going audience. They will review movies from all genres. So the same person that reviews 'Saw 3' has to go to the theatre and review 'Babe'. If you want a hardcore horror movie review, you would go to bloody-disgusting.com where the reviewer only reviews a certain type of movie."
by electrichead

Post new comment

Mollom CAPTCHA (play audio CAPTCHA)
Type the characters you see in the picture above; if you can't read them, submit the form and a new image will be generated.

Featured Group Content


IdeaPals - business social networking groups, entrepreneur meetups, events, project management, free job listings

Ideas need a place to grow. Create an idea group at IdeaPals.org and post events, jobs, videos, set goals, manage tasks and much more.